Monday, Feb. 19, 1940

Unchained?

Last May Colorado's Supreme Court decided that the independently owned retail outlets of Gamble-Skogmo, Inc. (auto accessories) were not a "voluntary" chain of stores, were therefore fair game for the State's chain-store tax. With that ruling for a club, Colorado went after bigger game. To General Motors, Ford, Chrysler, Hudson, Studebaker, Nash and Packard went bills totaling $531,120 for four years' chain-store license fees ($2.50 to $300.50 a store). Grounds: their franchise system and supervision of dealers made them operators of a chain.

To bat for the seven motormakers went Ford. If the tax could be made to stick, 22 other States with chain-store taxes might follow Colorado's lead and submit their own bills for license fees. That would play hob with the entire system of automobile distribution. Refusing to pay its $199,363 bill, Ford asked the Denver district court for a ruling.

Last week it got one. Ruled Judge Henry A. Hicks: ". . . The [Ford] dealers are in every sense of the word independent merchants. . . . Plaintiff and its dealers are not a chain-store system. ..." The motormakers breathed more easily. But Colorado got ready to appeal the case to its Supreme Court.

This file is automatically generated by a robot program, so reader's discretion is required.