American Notes Florida

When Roswell Gilbert, 76, received a life sentence last spring for killing his ailing 73-year-old wife, many Americans were torn. He had unquestionably broken the law; he had also ended the suffering of a woman racked by Alzheimer's disease and an agonizing bone illness. Last week, after months of weighing the issue, Florida's Democratic Governor Bob Graham recommended that Gilbert be released, at least on a provisional basis. Graham asked for a conditional commutation "to permit Gilbert to conduct his appeal from his home rather than from the state correctional system." For Gilbert to be granted clemency, at least half the six-member state cabinet must concur with the Governor's proposal. At week's end two members voiced support of Graham's recommendation and two opposed it. In prison, Gilbert has lost 40 lbs. and has undergone surgery for a urinary-tract condition. Graham said his proposal "represents an act of mercy extended to an elderly defendant in ill health, and does not indicate that what Mr. Gilbert did is sanctioned by the people of Florida."